Sustainability BMC

Report: The Future of Sustainability at Bryn Mawr

Section I - Our Goals

Small Goals 

May be implemented immediately, but they need leadership commitment and/or resources from college administration, faculty, and/or staff.


Increase college’s sustainability communication (LS, 1, p.g. 1-3)

  • Examples of desirable subjects of communication: waste, student action, energy usage, relationship w/ surrounding community, sourcing campus food, transportation footprint, sustainability efforts and their intersection with other social justice efforts Sharing information through multiple channels, such as on social media, other digital platforms, and verbally at campus events and gatherings.
    • Collecting data about student, faculty, and staff sustainability efforts on campus, and sharing this out via the appropriate channels.
  • Using resources more efficiently: no single waste plastic, and limiting paper use (LS, 1, p.g. 2; LS, 2, p.g. 1); Making sustainability a prioritywhen holding events (LS, 1, p.g. 1)
  • Clearer signage on waste bins about trash, recycling, and compost—i.e. what is included in each. People are often confused about what trash is and what recycling is. (LS, 1, p.g. 2; LS, 2, p.g. 2)
  • Digitally storing and sharing the work of student climate groups on campus like Sunrise and Green Ambassadors (LS, 1, p.g. 4)

Medium Goals

Are achievable in the short and long-term but will require additional monetary commitment as well as potential hiring.


Strengthen connections across the Tri-Co

  • Liais with sustainability leaders at Haverford and Swarthmore (LS, 1, p.g. 4)
  • Incorporate the perspective of different groups on campus (ex: Sunrise, Green Ambassadors, Bryn Mawr College Mujeres, and Mawrters for Immigrant Justice) and unifying our sustainability goals (LS, 2, p.g. 1)

Holding sustainability trainings for faculty, staff, and students (LS,1, p.g. 2 + 3)

  • Examples: OneDrive/Outlook, impacts of AI, etc.

Cleaning up systemic inefficiency (lights, heat, A/C) across campus (LS, 2, p.g. 1 + 2)

  • Add more heat control sensors or get rid of sensors to let students control temperature.
  • Installation of energy-efficient washers, having rain barrels to use rainwater for watering landscape (LS, 1, p.g. 1; LS, 2, p.g. 2)

Improving food and gardening efforts on campus (LS, 2, p.g. 1 + 2)

  • Sourcing food locally; connecting with PhillyFoodworks
  • Finding ways to better use and give away, food waste
  • Expanding community garden and having year-round garden education
  • Better use of greenhouses on campus or creation of a sustainability-centered greenhouse connected to the garden.

Investing in sustainable science equipment (LS, 2, p.g. 1)

  • Having community freecycle events, where people can share furniture and materials (LS, 2, p.g. 2)
  • SEPTA passes for staff and faculty to encourage public transportation use (LS, 1, p.g. 1 + 2; LS, 2, p.g. 2)
  • Special recycling collection and distribution services for batteries, electronics, Styrofoam, plastic bags, etc. Rabbit recycling could be a potential partner (LS, 2, p.g. 2)
  • Composting machines on campus (LS, 2, p.g. 2)

Large Goals

Requires considerable material efforts (monetary support, etc.) and may also require rethinking the boundaries of sustainability and the organizational structures that make environmental change possible on campus.


Building and implementing a sustainability budget (LS, 1, p.g. 3)

Enhancing sustainability curriculum (LS, 1, p.g. 1 +2)

  • Providing more course options
  • Spreading communication about sustainability course offerings that currently exist

Collaborate and partner with local community in Philadelphia and Lower Merion to spread our sustainability efforts beyond Bryn Mawr (LS, 1, p.g. 1 + 2) 

Sustainable landscaping efforts (LS, 1, p.g. 2; LS, 2, p.g. 1)

Becoming carbon neutral (LS, 1, p.g. 2; LS, 2, p.g. 2)

Investing in sustainable infrastructure (LS, 1, p.g. 2)

Honoring Indigenous practices of the land the college is on (LS, 1, p.g.3)

Aquifer thermal energy storage (LS, 2, p.g. 1)

Investing in more solar panels (LS, 2, p.g. 2)

Partnering with Sustainable Companies/nonprofits (LS, 2, p.g. 2)

  • Example: Terracycle, Rabbit Recycling, Circular Philly

*Note: LS stands for Listening Session, which were open to all members of the college.

 

Short-Term and Long-Term Goals

Short-term goals can be implemented relatively easily and require only maintenance checks once implemented.

Improving signage around campus so that members of the community are appropriately recycling and/or disposing of waste could be easily implemented through the President's Office. Research regarding where our waste goes, and what is and is not compostable should be included in this work. Figuring out the most effective methods of communication is an essential part of improving signage. Along this line, we also see an intersection with an interest among community members in increasing the college's sustainability communication. We are aware that this is something the President's Office is working on, and we recommend that this work continue to be shared with the college community.

Most of the above are small goals, yet some of the medium goals listed in the previous section may also be completed in the short-term. Installation of energy efficient washers, rain barrels, and other machines and technology on campus could be a relatively easy and fast, though pricey, change to make on campus. This reflects the community’s desire to add heat control sensors to dorms and buildings--though it's unclear to us what the current program's footprint is--as well as investing in sustainable science equipment.

We also suggest that having a community freecycle event could be easy to implement, perhaps once a semester, as well as hosting 1-2 events per semester around special recycling for batteries, electronics, Styrofoam, and plastics. We recommend connecting with Rabbit Recycling for these efforts.

Longer-term efforts typically fall into the medium and larger goals categories. In our review here, we hope to highlight what seems most possible and group some of the suggestions together so that they are categorically linked. Long-term goals require multiple areas of the college to come together to implement and need sustained commitment to continue these sustainability efforts over time.

Among the most striking of the long-term goals is the creation of a public sustainability budget. We feel that this would be best produced through a coalition of members--the President's Office, the new sustainability hire, and supporting students and faculty. We believe the budget should be public and easily accessible so that the community can remain on the same page about costs and goals. Becoming carbon-neutral is another long-term goal that is related in process to the creation of the budget. We recommend the same committee/task force be involved in overseeing this.

There are longer-term material changes that community members would also like to see. We imagine that these changes could be part of the carbon-neutral plan. These changes include aquifer thermal energy storage, additional solar panel installation, and creating a sustainable landscape plan. Creating a sustainable landscape plan overlaps the expressed desire to engage local Indigenous communities with regard to land stewardship on campus. We wonder what it might be like to include in the hiring of the new sustainability position a focus on Indigenous practice and/or a desire to build across regional settler and Indigenous land practices with the expressed goal of sustainable landscape design/use.

Collaboration with our nearby neighbors in the township, and in Philadelphia, is also important to the community. Equitable and inclusive social actions, including environmental justice actions, should be developed in partnership with community members. We think that the Civic Engagement Office could be brought into this conversation, and that, if they have bandwidth, they would be excellent support for this effort. It is very likely that many connections already exist, and that engaging these connections more fully could lead to stronger sustainability connections regionally, and greater resilience as we head into an uncertain climate change future.

Agriculture on campus is important to community members, and they see lots of space for improvement in the use of the gardens as well as existing greenhouses. A key part of these efforts would also be to encourage sustainable and locally based food production as well as provide hands-on education opportunities. Additionally, this goal can be effectively integrated into the workings of the sustainable landscape plan, engaging Indigenous practice, as well as the creation of the carbon budget and carbon neutrality.

We believe that these goals should not only be integrated into the job ad, but we also believe that we can begin to meet some of these long-term goals by creating a physical sustainability hub on campus. An example of this is how we imagine something like a sustainability-centered greenhouse, that can be used for agroecology, composting, beekeeping, and meetings of various fellows, faculty, and staff. This reflects the president’s vision of having our campus be a place where we engage with learning and acting together. We hope Bryn Mawr’s sustainability vision centers around these principles as they best reflect the unique perspectives of our community and where we hope to go as a collective.

Summary of Findings

Short and long-term goals the Bryn Mawr community is passionate about: 

  • Increasing sustainability communication
  • Energy-efficient appliances and technologies on campus
  • Free-cycling events, plastic, and battery recycling events
  • Public sustainability budget
  • Carbon neutrality
  • Aquifer thermal energy storage
  • Solar panel installation
  • Sustainability landscape plan
  • Land stewardship in connection with Indigenous groups
  • Collaboration with township neighbors, and the city of Philadelphia

Reflection

Considering the smallmedium, and large goals listed above, we consider the short—and long-term goals that rise to the top of these lists.

Section II - Peer Research


In addition to Bryn Mawr, many institutions are trying to develop sustainability efforts that care for both the planet and people. Making sure sustainability efforts are interdisciplinary and centered on climate justice are priorities that institutions have been implementing. After detailed research of other institutions’ Sustainability Plans, the efforts that stood out as most impactful are briefly reviewed below. The idea is that these efforts can inspire the progression of action that the Bryn Mawr community has deemed of importance to them.

Institutions Aligned with Sustainability Efforts

In addition to Bryn Mawr, many institutions are trying to develop sustainability efforts that care for both the planet and people. Making sure sustainability efforts are interdisciplinary and centered on climate justice are priorities that institutions have been implementing. After detailed research of other institutions’ Sustainability Plans, the efforts that stood out as most impactful are briefly reviewed below. The idea is that these efforts can inspire the progression of action that the Bryn Mawr community has deemed of importance to them.

  • Include carbon damage charge for travel and carbon shadow price for building
  • Offset all employee business and study abroad air travel
  • Have annual environmental justice courses taught
  • Develop an energy website for the college that displays the college’s current energy usage and energy data in one place that is accessible
  • Develop Green Purchasing Guidelines
  • Ensure that a minimum of 5% food purchases are locally sourced
  • Standardize campus recycling signage
  • Develop Restorative Land Management Guidelines and commit to a compliance of 80% of all outdoor practices on campus
  • Assessing flights sponsored by the college and seeing if more sustainable modes of travel like trains would be feasible
  • Expanding the ecological diversity on campus through landscape design and maintenance
    • Signage about plants and species
  • The Sustainable Office Certification and Sustainable Living Certification Programs for offices and dorms
  • Student run campaigns like Sustainability Month Energy Competition, RecycleMania, Coal Action Week, and Earth Week
  • Create a Center for the Environment
  • Incorporating sustainability into first-year orientation
  • Environmental Dashboard project (a good example of sharing sustainability progress through an interactive platform)
  • Adam Joseph Lewis Center (a good example of a learning laboratory used for sustainability)
  • Develop an Integrated Pest Management plan
  • Develop a digital resource for sustainability internships, careers, opportunities, etc.
  • Food Recovery Network helps donate excess food to local community
  • Make sustainability a priority for the Office of Engagement
  • Catalog and measure the carbon sequestration of plots of forested land
  • Arboretum events
  • Window replacements
  • Hamilton Cram and Scram
  • Replace existing heating steam infrastructure with a low-temperature hit water (LTHW) system --> eventually implementing geothermal energy
  • Electric-powered maintenance equipment for landscaping
  • Tracking university spending with underrepresented businesses
  • Procurement from small, local, women, and minority-owned business
  • Contribute to neighborhood canopy + more green spaces in community
  • Making sure relations with community are accountable, inclusive, equitable, and do not create an extractive dynamic
  • Co-create research project with community organizations

Summary of Findings

Ideas/Action to Mimic: 

  • Carbon budget might include: carbon damage charge; carbon damage pricing.
  • Green Purchasing Guidelines
  • Restorative Land Management Guidelines
  • Events: Sustainability Month Energy Competition, RecycleMania, and
    Oil Action Week
  • First-year sustainability education
  • LTHW system
  • Environmental dashboard / energy website

Reflection

Based on the interests of community members as outlined in section I, some efforts here resonate more than others.

With respect to creating a carbon budget, we want to highlight that Williams College does a carbon damage charge for travel and carbon
shadow pricing for building projects. We thought that was a unique way to think about budgeting carbon. Additionally, Vassar College developed an
energy website that displays usage and other data, and this might be a helpful tool in engaging the creation of a carbon budget as well as increasing sustainability communication. We also appreciated that they developed green purchasing guidelines, which could aid in our goal of using sustainable materials on campus, and centering local food production in campus consumption. Their development of restorative land management guidelines might also be a way to think about melding Indigenous land practices alongside ongoing settler uses. Another example to look at is Oberlin's environmental dashboard, which may help us imagine sharing the sustainability work of the college.

Wellesley's events like the Sustainability Month Energy Competition, RecycleMania, and Coal Action Week might be reshaped by student or staff groups at Bryn Mawr to reach some of our goals regarding recycling single waster plastics, disposing of batteries and electronics
properly, as well as shifting energy use in dorms and buildings. Wellesley has also incorporated sustainability into first-year education, including orientation. Perhaps working with Customs week planning, Customs people, and the Emily Balch seminars could yield a similar impact.

Bowdoin replaced existing heating steam infrastructure with a low -temperature heat water (LTHW) system, with the eventual goal of geothermal. This could be a helpful stepping stone for us as well, as we try to meet the goal of sustainable energy usage in dorms and campus buildings.

The actions taken by our peer institutions can guide our way towards accomplishing the sustainability goals of our community. We want to highlight that when looking at efforts of other colleges, it is not just about implementing pieces of their actions, but also working to transform how we think about the scope of environmental practices.

Section III - Conclusions


Based on our community listening sessions, here are the items the community would like to see in the near future.

  • Increasing sustainability communication
  • Energy-efficient appliances and technologies on campus
  • Free-cycling events, plastic and battery recycling events
  • Public sustainability budget
  • Carbon neutrality
  • Aquifer thermal energy storage
  • Solar panel installation
  • Sustainability landscape plan
  • Land stewardship in connection with Indigenous groups
  • Collaboration with township neighbors, and city of Philadelphia

Based on the sustainability efforts of our peer institutions, here are the actions that we can mimic that also resonate with our existing campus interests.

  • Carbon budget might include: carbon damage charge; carbon damage pricing
  • Restorative Land Management Guidelines
  • Green purchasing Guidelines
  • Events: Sustainability Month Energy Competition, RecycleMania, and Oil Action Week
  • First-year sustainability education
  • LTHW system
  • Environmental dashboard / energy website

Section IV - Director of Sustainability and Environmental Action

The Director of Sustainability and Environmental Action leads environmental efforts at Bryn Mawr College by envisioning, building, implementing, and managing sustainable development in support of environmental action and justice on campus. The Director will develop and advance initiatives, act as a liaison and leader for students, faculty, and staff, foster and manage collaborations with local stakeholders, and will be responsible for internal and external environmental data reporting.

This position reports directly to the VP of Finance and Administration with a dotted line to the Chief of Staff and works alongside the Director of Facilities and faculty leaders. The role will work closely with key partners on campus like the Civic Engagement Office, Transportation Services, Dining Services, Facilities, Library and Information Technology Services, and faculty, students, and staff to ensure sustainability initiatives are incorporated into daily operations, planning, construction, student life, and curricula. As a sustainability liaison for the college, the Director fosters collaboration with off-campus stakeholders to manage and lead sustainability goals as they engage our changing ecosystems and environments in conversation with our regional neighbors, surrounding communities, and Tri-Co partners. The Director will be a strategist with entrepreneurial experience who will lead our sustainability program through innovation with an explicit goal of long-term and sustained carbon neutrality.

Development, Strategy, and Partnership – 50%

Develop and execute an environmental action and sustainability strategy rooted in sustainable energy usage, land stewardship, sustainable operations and practices, and curricular innovation. Spearhead studies that deepen the approach to this strategy like an energy audit, a waste stream study or food stream assessment, and a land use study. Build initiatives that envision solutions to the results of the conducted studies, such as a waste management plan, a decarbonization plan, a sustainable food systems program, green purchasing guidelines, sustainable building practices, and a restorative land stewardship plan. Develop collaborative partnerships with internal partners and local organizations, townships, and groups, including Recycling and Waste organizations, regional agroecology and Indigenous tribes and nations, as well as Lower Merion Township, and the Pennsylvania Environmental Commission (PEC), to work together on strategic campus initiatives. Engage faculty expertise and on campus committees to enhance and strengthen sustainability curriculum, including programing for first-year students within Customs Week and/or Thrive. Highlight sustainability course offerings to students, including TriCo offerings, and work with faculty to increase sustainability course offerings.

Monitoring, Internal and External Reporting – 10%

Track metrics, report to Second Nature, and complete the AASHE STARS report. Create an Environmental Dashboard for the college that makes public our environmental actions, sustainable development strategies, and progress in real time. Collect, monitor, digitize, and report progress of student sustainability groups like Green Ambassadors and Sunrise.

Multiple Domains of Knowledge and Practice

  • Expertise in the areas of sustainability policies, sustainable building, environmental conservation, energy transformation, waste systems, or sustainable food systems.
  • Demonstrated ability to unite multiple, and intersecting, areas of sustainability knowledge and practice, such as sustainable building and environmental action.
  • Expertise in environmental data collection, processing, and reporting. 
  • Knowledge of sustainability principles including the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals and the Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education (AASHE). Interpreting and consistently applying a wide variety of complex policies and procedures where specific guidelines may not always exist.
  • Demonstrated ability to manage the details necessary to implement environmental action and sustainability efforts; a high level of productivity and accuracy / attention to detail.
  • Possession of strong analytical and research skills with a demonstrated ability to gather, evaluate, and to develop well-reasoned conclusions and recommendations.
  • Demonstrated experience in management, leadership, and aspects of programming.

Communication

  • A demonstrated ability to develop sustainability communications that are transparent and accessible to internal and external stakeholders, both verbal and in writing.
  • Expertise in engaging a diverse range of methods of communication involving computer proficiency with a variety of applications from word processing, spreadsheets, databases, online systems, social media platforms, Internet as well as online calendaring and email.
  • Passion for deep listening in engaging faculty, staff, students, and regional stakeholders.

Community Leadership

  • Willingness to and work effectively in a bureaucratic environment which requires regular interaction with a number of levels within the organization and multiple outside agencies.
  • Excellent organizational and time management skills with the demonstrated ability to set own priorities to coordinate multiple assignments with fluctuating and time-sensitive deadlines.
  • Flexibility and the ability to communicate effectively even under pressure or moments of contention.
  • Expertise, and proven track-record in, initiating, establishing, and fostering teamwork by maintaining a positive, cooperative, productive work atmosphere within a diverse population and with those from various cultural backgrounds.
  • Demonstrated ability to provide training and direction to student assistants.
  • Working knowledge or ability to quickly learn, university infrastructure, policies, and procedures.

 

Bachelor's degree required; Advanced degree, or equivalent work experience preferred, in a relevant field, such as Environmental Studies, Environmental Science, Engineering, Landscape Architecture, Urban Planning, Public Policy, Sustainability Management, Energy Systems, Ecology, Engineering, Architecture, Urban Planning, or Public Policy, or related social science/environmental degree

  • 7-10 years of experience in a related field

Sustainability Leadership Group

The Sustainability Leadership Group (SLG) was formed to direct the implementation of the Climate Action Plan and organize college-wide sustainability programs. The Climate Action Plan aims to reduce the carbon footprint of the College by 10 percent over the span of ten years.